READING REPORT REVIEW FORM

Report Group Members:
Reviewers' Name: 

For the following categories, please assign integer scores from 1 to 4
using the following criteria--
 1:  Outstanding   (Reflects clear understanding of the material and
 provides useful insight)
 2:  Good          (Addresses many important points)
 3:  Weak          (Does not address some important points/ has some
 mistakes) 
 4:  Unacceptable  (Has many mistakes, does not address any important
 points) 
 
Presentation: 
Technical Depth: 
Correctness:
Overall rating:

Please give detailed comments below. 

Main Contribution(s):

Positive Aspect(s):

Negative Aspect(s):

Overall Summary:

Detailed Comments (explain here in detail the shortcomings of the report):